Purl and Seam

handmade in Lancashire

The Gentleman’s Wardrobe – Book Review

May 12, 2017

Sewing for my man isn’t something I’ve done a lot of in the past, although he’s not short of woolly socks! I’m hoping to do more for him in the future, but there is a dearth of good menswear patterns out there.

So it was with bated breath that I’ve been awaiting my copy of The Gentleman’s Wardrobe, Vintage-Style Projects to Make for the Modern Man by Vanessa Mooncie.

The book is beautiful to look at.  The styling is reminiscent of Japanese sewing books. Moody shots in a modern industrial setting.  Whilst the styling appeals to the “hipster” look my husband likes, the patterns are really quite classic.

The shirts, trousers and a jacket could all be made up in different fabrics to achieve different looks.  They are the kind of patterns that once you’ve got the fit nailed you’d have a set of basic styles that you could make over and over again for the man in your life.

There’s also a selection of useful accessories and nightwear.

It really does cover all the bases.  The only thing really missing would be an overcoat.  But that’s nit picking.

The book is, for a change, not aimed at the beginner sewist.  There are some basic techniques included, but this is not a “learn to sew’ book.

There are full sized pattern sheets included.  They do require tracing but are nowhere near as busy as a Burda pattern sheet so should pose no trouble.

As you can imagine I was really excited to look through this book and was, quite frankly, planning to make everything except the wallet and bow tie and short sleeved shirt for my mister.  The styles are that good and these are the only garments he wouldn’t wear.

And then I checked the size chart.

My man has a 19″ neck.  And his chest is definitely more than a 42! The grading to get these to size would be ridiculous.

And lets be honest.  As with us ladies, the 16″ neck market is widely served with both RTW and vintage patterns.  This was a great opportunity to hit an untapped and underserved market with cool patterns that a wide range of men would be glad to wear.

Sadly it’s an opportunity that once again has been missed.

Thankfully I’d ordered this from the library to “audition” it.  It’s not a book I’ll be buying.

I’m so disappointed!

Related

CATEGORIES // Reviews

« The goats of Inversnaid
Sewing room reveal »

RELATED POSTS

  • Made by Rae Geranium Dress – maxi sundress hack
  • Helen’s Closet Blackwood Cardigan
  • DIY Dressform Pattern – feedback from the designerDIY Dressform Pattern – feedback from the designer
  • Sewn Magazine – Review

Comments

  1. Dottie Doodle says

    May 12, 2017 at 4:45 pm

    What a shame! Looks like a great book otherwise.

    • Pendle Stitches says

      May 25, 2017 at 10:49 am

      I know! It’s a great book apart from that one, rather critical, flaw!

  2. Chica andaluza says

    May 13, 2017 at 8:15 am

    What a shame about the sizing. I’d have the same issue. The clothes look beautiful but clearly aimed ( like many patterns for us) at the smaller bodied folk!

    • Pendle Stitches says

      May 25, 2017 at 10:50 am

      It’s such a shame! And hugely frustrating. I know that there has to be some sort of middle ground, but it just seems to be so short sighted, whether in sewing patterns or RTW.

  3. Mother of Reinvention says

    May 14, 2017 at 9:45 am

    That is absolutely terrible. Since when was a large a 42″ chest? I think that they have shot themselves in the foot with the sizing on this one. I was getting all excited too as decent menswear patterns are pretty thin on the ground. I suppose that this is the men’s versions of all those lovely sewing books that I would have to grade up so much I would be quicker drafting things myself. Oh well, maybe one day. 🙂 Xx

    • Pendle Stitches says

      May 25, 2017 at 10:53 am

      I agree! There is this huge market that’s completely untapped. I know David Coffin’s books are good for tweaking shirt patterns, but there is plenty of room for some cool new patterns.

  4. Carmen says

    May 15, 2017 at 3:36 am

    I agree! There are never any cool mens patterns anywhere.

    • Pendle Stitches says

      May 25, 2017 at 10:53 am

      Nope….it’s rubbish, really.

  5. Jane says

    May 15, 2017 at 7:26 pm

    Ah what a shame. Having only three size brackets is bad enough, but using such small sizes is just absurd. My husband is a very slim man and he’d be a combination of Medium/Large in this book! It’s bonkers – they’ve really missed a trick there. x

    • Pendle Stitches says

      May 25, 2017 at 10:54 am

      They have indeed. Such a shame.

  6. Chica Andaluza says

    May 16, 2017 at 9:24 am

    Looks like my comment didn’t work first time around! I agree with the others on here, such a shame about the sizing. The styles are beautiful though, how disappointing ?

    • Pendle Stitches says

      May 25, 2017 at 10:54 am

      😉

  7. Tialys says

    May 17, 2017 at 6:09 am

    Japanese sizing as well as Japanese styling 🙁

    • Pendle Stitches says

      May 25, 2017 at 10:54 am

      Absolutely! 🙁

  8. Kim says

    May 24, 2017 at 6:02 pm

    So sad, this could have been really useful. I’m glad you were able to check out a library copy. Have you checked the Winnie Aldrich Menswear pattern cutting book? It may possibly be better for your needs. (If you can’t get a copy to look at contact me and I can loan you mine)

    • Pendle Stitches says

      May 25, 2017 at 10:56 am

      I have the woman’s and kids books (thank you very much 😉 ). I think I’ll get a copy of the mens from the library and check it out.

      Our library is great. If they haven’t got a book in stock you can order it and they’ll try and get it for you for the pittance of 60p! It’s a great way of auditioning books without any commitment. And if you love them….then they can get added to the bookshelf!

Evie

Looking for something?

Never miss a post!

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts in your inbox.

Topics

books craft projects dressmaking embroidery fabric finished objects 2010 finished projects 2011 finished projects 2012 finished projects 2013 finished projects 2014 finished projects 2015 finished projects 2016 finished projects 2017 finished projects 2018 finished projects 2019 finished projects 2020 fitting giveaways hand knitting helens_closet house and garden in the sewing room kcw - spring 2013 kcwc - fall 2012 knitting knitting for men knitting my stash life in a Northern town made by ma! my family and other animals patterns quilting reviews sewing for girls sewing goals 2019 sewinggoals2020 sewing my own clothes sewing my stash sewing with knits sewover50 stash goals 2019 stash stories that bloody wedding! travelling yarn

Recent Posts

  • DIY Hand Knit Sweater – Tulip by Ririko
  • DIY Dancewear – trousers and a modified Jalie 2803 stretch bodysuit
  • DIY Hello Kitty Patchwork and Embroidery Quilt
  • 13
  • DIY Upcycled Tops

Disclosure Policy

Occasionally I’ll include affiliate links in my posts.   If you click through and make a  purchase, I may receive a small commission, at no cost to you!  As you’d expect, I only recommend goods or services that I think are awesome and worth sharing.

THEME BY ECLAIR DESIGNS